Claims Adjuster Interview Questions
For property and casualty claims examiners who review insurance settlements. Interviews focus on spotting payment errors and checking that settlements follow company procedures.
30 questions, ranked by what the job needs most
Also for Claims Adjuster: Customer Service Representatives · Insurance Adjusters, Examiners, and Investigators · Insurance Appraisers, Auto Damage · all 5 sets →
Print the top 10:Scoring sheetPractice sheet
Question 1: Share an example of a time a policy exclusion changed your recommendation on a property or casualty claim.
Interviewer tipListen for the examiner's own comparison of the exclusion with the claim facts and any wording that limits the exclusion. Recommending denial from an exclusion's heading alone is a red flag.
Candidate tipChoose one examiner review. Explain the exclusion, the claim facts you checked, your recommendation, and how the claim was resolved. Include what the review taught you about reading the full policy.
Question 2: Describe how you brought a difficult claim to a fair and prompt settlement.
Example answerThe interviewer wants to learn whether you can settle a difficult claim fairly without letting avoidable delays build up.
Use Situation, Task, Action, Result to organize one real claim. Briefly explain the dispute and your responsibility. Spend most of the answer on your coverage checks, evidence review, settlement reasoning and communication. End with the outcome and a lesson about keeping a difficult file moving.
For example: "A claimant disputed our repair estimate, and we still needed information about the damage. I reviewed the policy and compared the estimate with the inspection notes. I identified the missing details and requested them together rather than sending separate requests. I kept the claimant updated while I reviewed the response. The added evidence supported a revised amount within my authority, and the claimant accepted the settlement. I learned to identify gaps early so the same file does not keep returning for more information."
Avoid claiming speed mattered more than a supported payment, skipping your own role or sharing identifying claim details.
Interviewer tipListen for their own coverage and fact checks, a supported settlement amount and a clear result. Paying an unsupported amount just to close the claim is a red flag.
Candidate tipChoose one difficult claim. Explain your checks of the policy and evidence, how you kept the settlement moving, the result and what you learned about avoiding delays.
Question 3: Describe a time you found an unsupported assumption in an adjuster's report while reviewing a claim for payment.
Interviewer tipThey should identify the assumption, test it against the file and explain its effect on payment review. Repeating the adjuster's conclusion without checking its support is a red flag.
Candidate tipUse one report with a specific unsupported statement. Explain your checks, the clarification you requested and the effect on the payment decision. End with what you learned about reviewing reports.
Question 4: Describe a time you had to qualify a claim recommendation because the investigation left an important fact unresolved.
Interviewer tipListen for a clear line between established facts and open questions in their recommendation. Presenting an unverified account as a confirmed finding is a red flag.
Candidate tipUse one investigation with a gap in the evidence. Describe how you stated that limit in your findings, what you could recommend and how the review turned out. Include a lesson about reporting uncertainty.
Question 5: Talk about a time you handled pressure to pay or deny a claim on terms the facts did not support.
Example answerThe interviewer wants to learn whether you base claim decisions on the policy and evidence when someone pressures you to do otherwise.
Use Situation, Task, Action, Result to explain a real ethical challenge. State the pressure and your responsibility without identifying the people involved. Focus on the facts you checked, your response and any escalation. End with the outcome and what you learned.
For example: "An agent pressed me to approve a settlement amount that included damage the file did not support. I reviewed the policy, estimate and inspection notes before responding. I explained the gap in the evidence and documented the request and my reasons in the claim file. When the pressure continued, I brought the file to my supervisor. We kept the decision tied to the supported damage and invited additional evidence for the disputed amount. I learned to document the basis for a decision early so pressure does not replace a factual review."
Avoid changing a decision solely to satisfy pressure, claiming you refused without checking the facts or exposing identifying claim details.
Interviewer tipThe example should show their own response to pressure, support from the policy and evidence, and the outcome. Changing a claim decision solely to satisfy that pressure is a red flag.
Candidate tipDescribe one real case without identifying the people. Explain the pressure, the policy and facts you relied on, and your response. Finish with the outcome and what you learned about handling that pressure.
Question 6: How do you check your payment authority on a claim that already has several payments recorded?
Interviewer tipThey should check their authority limits against the proposed payment and prior payments, using the limits that apply to that claim. Splitting a payment to avoid an authority limit is a red flag.
Candidate tipWalk through checking the claim's payment history and your authority limits before processing the next payment. Explain when you would need further approval.
Question 7: Walk me through a time you settled part of a property claim while other items were still in dispute.
Interviewer tipA strong example separates supported amounts from unresolved items and shows the examiner's checks of policy terms and state rules. Holding every payment solely to pressure the claimant is a red flag.
Candidate tipExplain what was ready to settle, what remained disputed, and your own work to arrange the partial settlement. Include the applicable state rules you checked, the result, and what you learned.
Question 8: What would you check before approving a property claim payment to someone other than the named insured?
Interviewer tipExpect checks of the proposed payee's identity, entitlement and supporting authorization or policy terms. Changing the payee based only on an unverified request is a red flag.
Candidate tipExplain how you would confirm who is entitled to payment and check documents supporting a different payee, such as an assignment or mortgage interest. Describe how you would resolve missing authorization.
Question 9: Tell me about a time you caught a payment error while reviewing a settled property or casualty claim.
Interviewer tipA strong answer shows how the candidate traced the difference to a specific payment entry and what happened after they reported it. Signing off on a file with an unexplained difference is a red flag.
Candidate tipPick one settled claim and explain what you compared in the payment record and the approved settlement to confirm the error. End with what happened after you reported it.
Question 10: Tell me about a time you questioned an adjuster's expense recommendation after comparing medical bills with treatment records.
Interviewer tipThe example should identify a specific mismatch between the medical bills and treatment records and the examiner's own follow-up. Guessing a medical cause from an unfamiliar diagnosis is a red flag; ask what they learned.
Candidate tipChoose one claim review where bills and treatment records did not support the adjuster's recommendation. Explain what you compared, the clarification you sought, and how the expense decision turned out.
Question 11: How do you check the quantities and unit costs in a property damage estimate against the documented damage?
Interviewer tipA sound review compares quantities with measurements or photos and checks the basis for unit costs. Cutting costs by an arbitrary percentage is a red flag.
Candidate tipGo through the estimate's quantities and prices in order. Explain how you use damage records to test the scope of repairs and how you resolve a line item that lacks support.
Question 12: Give an example of how you cleared up a mismatch between a claimant's loss description and the dates on the claim form.
Interviewer tipLook for neutral questions, a documented correction and a clear outcome. Treating a date mismatch alone as proof of fraud is a red flag.
Candidate tipBriefly describe the conflicting dates and loss account. Focus on your correspondence with the claimant, the records used to clear it up and the result. Say what improved your later checks.
Question 13: Give an example of how you dealt with a claimant or agent who was angry about the handling of a claim.
Example answerThe interviewer wants to learn whether you can handle an angry claimant or agent with calm, clear communication.
Organize a real example using Situation, Task, Action, Result. Explain the complaint briefly, then focus on your own listening, file review and response. Include the outcome, even if the person remained dissatisfied, and a lesson you used in later conversations.
For example: "A claimant was angry because they expected payment before we had received a revised repair estimate. I let them explain their concern, then reviewed the claim notes so I could explain the delay accurately. I acknowledged that our updates had been unclear. I explained which estimate we still needed and agreed on a date for another update. I followed through on that date, even though the estimate was still pending. The claimant understood the next step and stopped making repeated calls. I learned that a clear update can help even when I cannot immediately resolve the claim."
Avoid blaming the claimant, promising an unsupported payment or describing the exchange without explaining your own actions.
Interviewer tipListen for what they did to understand the complaint, explain the claim's status and follow through. A clear outcome matters; promising an unsupported payment to end the argument is a red flag.
Candidate tipChoose one real complaint. Briefly explain the claimant's or agent's concern, then focus on how you listened, checked the file and responded. Include the outcome and what you learned from the exchange.
Question 14: How do you keep a witness interview from steering the witness toward the claimant's version of an accident?
Interviewer tipThey should use open prompts, keep accounts separate and record the witness's own words. Feeding the witness details they did not recall undermines the interview.
Candidate tipDescribe how you would invite an independent account before asking about gaps or differences. Explain how you keep the witness's recollection separate from information supplied by the claimant.
Question 15: How do you check that a reserve adjustment was entered on the right claim for the approved amount?
Interviewer tipExpect checks of the claim number, whether the amount is an adjustment or a new total, and the saved balance against the authorization. Leaving a known posting error uncorrected is a red flag.
Candidate tipWalk through comparing the saved reserve entry with the claim number and authorized adjustment. Explain how you check the resulting balance and handle a mismatch before treating the entry as complete.
Question 16: What would you do if you were asked to lower a claim reserve without any change in the claim's expected cost?
Interviewer tipCheck the basis for the reduction and use the insurer's reserve approval process. Lowering the reserve merely to improve reported financial results is a red flag.
Candidate tipStart by checking the reason for the requested reduction against the claim file and reserve rules. Explain how you would raise an unsupported request with the person responsible for reserve approval.
Question 17: Describe a time you cleared up who was responsible for work on a severe-loss claim handled by several adjusters.
Interviewer tipA strong case shows the candidate's role in resolving overlapping assignments and the effect on the claim. Assuming another adjuster had handled a needed review without confirming it is a red flag.
Candidate tipUse one severe-loss claim with overlapping assignments. Explain how you clarified each adjuster's work, kept the file moving, and checked the result. Include what you learned about coordinating claim reviews.
Question 18: Tell me about a time you helped legal counsel understand a disputed fact in a claim headed for litigation.
Interviewer tipThe example should show a factual briefing, clear source records and what counsel could do with it. Hiding evidence that weakens the claim position is a red flag.
Candidate tipChoose a disputed fact you helped counsel assess. Describe how you organized the claim records, explained gaps and answered questions. Close with the result and a lesson about preparing a useful briefing.
Question 19: What distinguishes a questionable claim that needs an investigator from one an adjuster can resolve through routine follow-up?
Interviewer tipExpect a distinction between ordinary claim clarification and concerns needing investigation, tied to the insurer's referral criteria. Treating every clerical error as proof of fraud is a red flag.
Candidate tipContrast a discrepancy an adjuster can verify with a concern that calls for investigative work. Explain how the claim's facts and the insurer's referral criteria guide the choice.
Question 20: Talk about a time you caught a claim that had dropped off your list of files needing detailed review.
Interviewer tipListen for the candidate's own checks, restored tracking, and the outcome for the claim. Adding the file back without checking whether its review was overdue leaves the problem unresolved.
Candidate tipExplain how you found the missing claim, restored it to the review list, and checked for missed deadlines. End with the review outcome and a change that helped keep the list accurate.
Question 21: What would you do if a business had not sent requested accident footage and counsel's evidence deadline was approaching?
Interviewer tipCounsel needs prompt notice of the missing footage, documented follow-up, and a chance to direct further collection. Letting the deadline pass without telling counsel is a red flag.
Candidate tipStart with how you would alert counsel to the missing footage and deadline. Explain your follow-up with the business and how you would seek counsel's direction if the footage remained unavailable.
Question 22: Recall how you obtained a missing treatment detail after a medical provider sent an incomplete response about a claim.
Interviewer tipListen for a focused request for the missing treatment detail and a clear result. Seeking an entire unrelated medical history instead is a red flag.
Candidate tipPick an incomplete provider response. State the detail missing, explain how you clarified the request within the claim's scope and describe the outcome. Include a lesson about making requests specific.
Question 23: How would you present a lengthy claim file to a committee deciding whether to settle or continue negotiations?
Interviewer tipExpect a clear decision to be made, a concise account of the claim, and supported settlement options. Recounting the entire file without identifying the decision the committee needs to make misses the purpose.
Candidate tipOrganize the presentation around the committee's decision. Explain how you would summarize the loss, disputed facts, settlement options, and the support for your recommendation.
Question 24: What details belong in a report of an underpayment on a settled property claim?
Interviewer tipExpect the claim identifier, paid and corrected amounts, calculation basis and records supporting the difference. Reporting a guessed shortfall as confirmed is a red flag.
Candidate tipOutline a report that lets the reviewer verify the underpayment. Include the payment history, corrected calculation, supporting policy terms and the status of any correction.
Question 25: What would you do if a claimant presented a much higher repair estimate for the first time during mediation?
Interviewer tipThey should review the new estimate with counsel before changing the settlement position and stay within their authority. Agreeing to the higher amount without reviewing it is a red flag.
Candidate tipExplain your first response to the new estimate, how you would compare it with the claim records and when you would involve counsel or seek more authority. Avoid promising an immediate increase.
Question 26: Tell me how you handled an overpayment or other irregularity you found while reviewing a settled claim.
Example answerThe interviewer wants to learn whether you can spot a problem in a settled claim and take responsibility for addressing it.
Build your answer with Situation, Task, Action, Result. Identify the record that caught your attention and your role in reviewing it. Explain how you confirmed the irregularity, documented the evidence and reported it for correction. Close with the result and a lesson for later reviews.
For example: "While reviewing a settled auto claim, I noticed two rental reimbursements covering the same dates. I checked the invoices and payment history to make sure they were separate payments rather than duplicate entries. I documented the overlap in the claim file and brought it to my supervisor for correction. The duplicate amount was confirmed, and I referred it for recovery through our claims process. I learned to compare service dates as well as invoice numbers when checking reimbursements."
Avoid treating a suspicion as a confirmed error, ignoring an overpayment because the file is closed or describing a correction that leaves no record.
Interviewer tipA strong example traces the error from the claim file through verification, reporting and correction. Ignoring a confirmed overpayment because the claim is closed is a red flag.
Candidate tipUse a real settled claim. Point to the record that raised concern, explain your checks and your part in addressing the error, then give the outcome and a lesson for future reviews.
Question 27: How do you make sure your claim decisions follow company procedures and the claim-handling rules in the states where you work?
Example answerThe interviewer wants to know you understand that claim handling is regulated, that the rules differ by state, and that you build checks into your daily work. This is a process question, so explain your habits and add a brief example. Cover how you keep up with company guidelines and state claim-handling rules, how you track time limits for acknowledging, investigating and paying claims, and how you document the reason for each decision. Sample answer: "I keep a reference sheet of the response deadlines for each state I handle, and I set diary reminders as soon as a claim comes in. When a guideline changes, I read the update and check my open files against it. Once, I noticed a claim from a state I rarely handled had a shorter deadline than I expected, so I sent the acknowledgment that day and shared the rule with my team." Pitfalls to avoid: claiming to know every state's rules from memory, treating compliance as someone else's job, and giving legal interpretations instead of checking with compliance staff or counsel when unsure.
Interviewer tipListen for specific habits, such as tracking state response deadlines, checking guidelines and documenting reasons. Knowing that rules vary by state is a plus; relying on memory alone is a red flag.
Candidate tipExplain how you stay current on state rules and company guidelines, and how you build checks into your files. A short example of catching a compliance issue helps.
Question 28: Walk me through how you prioritize a caseload of open claims when several have deadlines in the same week.
Example answerThe interviewer wants to see that you have a system for a heavy caseload and know which claims must come first. This is a process question, so walk through your method, then give a short example. Explain how you rank claims, for example by regulatory or court deadlines, severity and how long the claimant has waited, and how you track follow-ups. Sample answer: "Every morning I check my diary for deadlines that day and that week. Claims with response deadlines set by state rules or court dates come first, then severe injury or large loss claims, then routine files. During one busy week, I had a mediation, two claims nearing their response deadlines and a new large fire loss. I prepared the mediation file early, blocked time to send the two responses on time, and asked my supervisor to reassign two routine claims so the fire loss got a prompt first contact." Pitfalls to avoid: saying you just work harder or stay late, ignoring deadlines set outside the company, and describing a system you don't actually use.
Interviewer tipLook for a system that puts regulatory deadlines, severe claims and litigation dates first, and a way to track diaries or follow-ups. Working files in the order they arrived is a red flag.
Candidate tipDescribe how you sort claims, for example by deadline, severity and exposure, and the tools you use to track follow-ups. Give an example of a busy week and how it went.
Question 29: Share an experience in which you found a claim which need further investigation in order to authorize payments. What methods did you use?
Question 30: Provide an effective method you have used to ensure that claims are valid and that settlements are made according to company procedures.