Skip to content

Check Examiner Interview Questions

For property and casualty claims examiners who review insurance settlements. Interviews focus on spotting payment errors and checking that settlements follow company procedures.

30 questions, ranked by what the job needs most

Print the top 10:Scoring sheetPractice sheet

  1. Question 1: Share an example of a time a policy exclusion changed your recommendation on a property or casualty claim.

  2. Question 2: Describe how you brought a difficult claim to a fair and prompt settlement.

  3. Question 3: Describe a time you found an unsupported assumption in an adjuster's report while reviewing a claim for payment.

  4. Question 4: Describe a time you had to qualify a claim recommendation because the investigation left an important fact unresolved.

  5. Question 5: Talk about a time you handled pressure to pay or deny a claim on terms the facts did not support.

  6. Question 6: How do you check your payment authority on a claim that already has several payments recorded?

  7. Question 7: Walk me through a time you settled part of a property claim while other items were still in dispute.

  8. Question 8: What would you check before approving a property claim payment to someone other than the named insured?

  9. Question 9: Tell me about a time you caught a payment error while reviewing a settled property or casualty claim.

  10. Question 10: Tell me about a time you questioned an adjuster's expense recommendation after comparing medical bills with treatment records.

  11. Question 11: How do you check the quantities and unit costs in a property damage estimate against the documented damage?

  12. Question 12: Give an example of how you cleared up a mismatch between a claimant's loss description and the dates on the claim form.

  13. Question 13: Give an example of how you dealt with a claimant or agent who was angry about the handling of a claim.

  14. Question 14: How do you keep a witness interview from steering the witness toward the claimant's version of an accident?

  15. Question 15: How do you check that a reserve adjustment was entered on the right claim for the approved amount?

  16. Question 16: What would you do if you were asked to lower a claim reserve without any change in the claim's expected cost?

  17. Question 17: Describe a time you cleared up who was responsible for work on a severe-loss claim handled by several adjusters.

  18. Question 18: Tell me about a time you helped legal counsel understand a disputed fact in a claim headed for litigation.

  19. Question 19: What distinguishes a questionable claim that needs an investigator from one an adjuster can resolve through routine follow-up?

  20. Question 20: Talk about a time you caught a claim that had dropped off your list of files needing detailed review.

  21. Question 21: What would you do if a business had not sent requested accident footage and counsel's evidence deadline was approaching?

  22. Question 22: Recall how you obtained a missing treatment detail after a medical provider sent an incomplete response about a claim.

  23. Question 23: How would you present a lengthy claim file to a committee deciding whether to settle or continue negotiations?

  24. Question 24: What details belong in a report of an underpayment on a settled property claim?

  25. Question 25: What would you do if a claimant presented a much higher repair estimate for the first time during mediation?

  26. Question 26: Tell me how you handled an overpayment or other irregularity you found while reviewing a settled claim.

  27. Question 27: How do you make sure your claim decisions follow company procedures and the claim-handling rules in the states where you work?

  28. Question 28: Walk me through how you prioritize a caseload of open claims when several have deadlines in the same week.

  29. Question 29: Share an experience in which you found a claim which need further investigation in order to authorize payments. What methods did you use?

  30. Question 30: Provide an effective method you have used to ensure that claims are valid and that settlements are made according to company procedures.